Every year around this time, the web becomes littered with Tax Day posts, wherein pundits and average citizens alike bemoan the complexity of the tax code, celebrate the size of their refunds, complain about government waste, and countless other variations on the “I just paid my taxes and now I want to talk about it” theme.
In that vein, I ran across this “Tax Day Vent Thread” at conservative site RedState.org, which quickly turned into a debate over the competing merits of the Flat Tax and the Fair Tax. The Flat Tax is a scheme whereby the current system of taxation would be replaced by a single tax rate paid by everyone. The “Fair Tax,” on the other hand, is a system that would involve, among other things, a national sales tax, the repeal of the Sixteenth Amendment, various tax rebates, and the elimination of taxes on corporations.
Judging from the ensuing discussion, both systems have their fans, while everyone agrees that the existing system of taxation is burdensome, overly complicated, and most likely a scheme by evil, greedy, and corrupt Democratic politicians to make average Americans’ lives difficult and to line their pockets with ill-gotten gains.
I have stated before my firm belief that while conservative cries for a simpler, more equitable tax code might sound great in principle, they would never work in practice. It is, after all, not the nature of the current tax code that makes it complicated in principle, but rather the application of the code in practice to a nation of 300 million people and countless businesses and other entities. I would wager that any tax code, no matter how simple it sounds when described on RedState.org or by the Limbaugh/Hannity/Boortz crowd, would become just as byzantine as the current system if it were actually put into practice.
The constant, hectoring calls from the Right for “tax reform” fit a larger pattern, though. Go down the list of conservative talking points (I’m not going to sully the term “policies” by applying it here), and one after the other, they pretty much all fall into the category of simple ideas that sound great in paper but do not actually fit with anything in the real world:
- People should be able to manage their own retirement funds, so let’s privatize Social Security.
- Illegal immigration is out of control, so let’s make it a felony and build a wall across the border with Mexico.
- Saddam Hussein is evil, so let’s invade Iraq and make them democratic.
- Iran is evil, so let’s invade them and make them democratic.
- Government regulation is bad, so let’s eliminate it.
- Abortion is evil, so let’s outlaw it.
Each makes for a good soundbyte, but try to put it into practice in a complicated world filled with shades of gray, and its limitations quickly become evident.