There has been a story flitting around the web for a few days now about a group of men, all of middle-eastern descent, arrested in Michigan recently for purchasing large numbers of cellphones. Originally posted on the websites of several local Michigan newspapers, the story was picked up by a number of right-wing blogs, and has how surfaced in the mainstream press.
The facts of the case are that the three men drove to Michigan from Texas to purchase the phones. Police were alerted when the men attempted to buy big batches of phones from the local Wal-Mart, which has a three-per-purchase limit. The police, finding 1000 phones in the mens’ van, then arrested the men on charges of terrorism, citing a possible plot to blow up the bridge to Mackinac Island.
This whole story is just all kinds of stupid.
The idea that terrorists in Texas would travel to Michigan to blow up a bridge to Mackinac Island is patently ridiculous. If you are not familiar (which wouldn’t be surprising), Mackinac is a small island at the far northern tip of Lake Huron, right where the lower part of Michigan meets the Upper Peninsula. It is packed solid with overpriced hotels and shops, and serves as a tourist destination for denizens of the upper Midwest who would like to consider themselves well-heeled.
Ever since it dawned on the collective consciousness that the planes weren’t hitting the buildings by mistake, people across the country have been vastly overestimating the risk of terrorists attacking. In some cases, this failure to deal with the threat rationally is understandable—maybe the odds are low, the argument goes, but wouldn’t we rather be safe than sorry? At the opposite extreme are examples such as Indiana’s list of potential terror targets, which includes such high-value sites as a petting zoo and a popcorn factory. One can only assume that the motivation here is the treasure-trove of homeland security funding pouring out of federal coffers.
Either way, there is, in reality, just about zero chance that terrorists are going to attack anything in a small Midwest town that is not a large chemical plant or a nuclear power plant. Regardless of how important the local tourist destination might seem to area residents, none of this stuff is high-profile in the national sense that would qualify it as a likely terrorist target.
Which brings us back to the three guys arrested in Michigan.
Their explanation? They say they were buying the phones for resale, which seems like a pretty likely scenario to me. What makes it seem even more likely is the fact that local authorities have yet to provide any further explanation for the mens’ arrest other than that they “looked suspicious” (i.e., they’re Middle Eastern).
Perhaps it will turn out that these guys really were up to something nefarious, and that disaster at Mackinac Island has been narrowly averted by the vigilance of local authorities, but I doubt it. As with the columnist who raised all the ruckus a few years ago about the swarthy men on her flight engaging in highly suspicious activities such as going to the bathroom and talking to one another, this story looks to be a prime example of hysteria and racism.