Republican debate
I made it through about twenty minutes of last night’s Republican Presidential debate.
Watching the candidates dodge questions about what would happen if, come September, the situation in Iraq has shown no discernible improvement, I was reminded of a scene from Penelope Spheeris’s excellent 1988 documentary The Decline & Fall of Western Civilization II: The Metal Years.
At one point in the film, the director is talking to the singer of an unsigned hair metal band. The guy is sitting in a hot tub for the interview, drinking champagne and flanked by bikini-clad girls. He’s going on about how the band will get signed, become incredibly popular, and everything will be great.
“But what if you don’t get signed?” Spheeris asks him.
A blank look comes over his face. “There’s no way that can’t happen,” he says.
“Okay, but just for the sake of argument, imagine that it doesn’t. Do you have any other plans?”
The singer’s face remains blank, as though he’s been asked a question in some foreign language. “I can’t even imagine we won’t make it huge. It’s just impossible.”
Spheeris wisely moves on to another topic at this point.
Unfortunately, The Metal Years is not available on DVD. If it were, I would recommend renting it and comparing this scene to the endless variations on “We have to win” provided by the Republican front-runners. Despite all evidence to the contrary, these guys are still insisting that winning the war in Iraq is possible. We just have to try/wish hard enough, and stop listening to the defeatist, blame-America-first crowd (a.k.a., Democrats, liberals, and the news media).
Mitt Romney’s dodge was a straight-up lie, as he insisted we had no way of knowing that Saddam didn’t pose a real threat despite the fact that UN weapons inspectors were in Iraq pretty much right up until the U.S. invaded. McCain stuck to the same tired rhetoric he’s been using for the past few years—we’ve got to win, it’s a struggle for our existence, we need to put politics aside, blah blah blah. Meanwhile, Giuliani went with his tried-and-true “9/11, 9/11, 9/11, 9/11, the brown-skinned people want to kill you” line.
I didn’t make it much further through the debate. Around the point when every single candidate expressed being willing and ready to nuke Iran, I found myself growing too disgusted to continue watching. I finally turned it off once they started falling all over each other declaring the evils of amnesty of illegal aliens.
For the record, this is way too early for election season to be starting.
UPDATE: Digby, as usual, sums the debate up pretty well:
The rhetoric coming out of these guys is really quite extreme, even by GOP standards, but I guess that’s just because the front runners are all a bunch of flipflopping hypocrites who have to fake some kind of red-meat qualifications for the base. They’ve opted for bullying machismo, which is actually quite smart. It’s the tie that binds. They certainly have given up on the “law ‘n order” platform with their nearly unanimous support for a Scooter pardon — especially the ex-federal prosecutor Giuliani who couldn’t stop whining and twisting his little lace hankie about how unfair it all was.