More Libby
Twelve paragraphs into the New York Times’ “news analysis” piece on the Libby clemency, we read the following:
Indeed, to administration critics, the commutation was a subversion of justice, an act of hypocrisy by a president who once vowed that anyone in his administration who broke the law would “be taken care of.â€
Howard Dean, the chairman of the Democratic Party, called it a “get- out-of-jail-free card.†Representative Nancy Pelosi, the speaker of the House, called it “a betrayal of trust of the American people.â€
But to the conservative believers who make up Mr. Bush’s political base, the Libby case was a test of the president’s political will. In the end, although he did not go so far as to pardon Mr. Libby, Mr. Bush apparently decided that it was a test he did not want to fail.
Given that the title of the article is (at least as of 7:43 this morning) “For Bush, Action in Libby Case Was a Test of Will”, it is fairly clear that the Times falls in with the latter crowd in this case. The paper then proceeds to quote editor of the Weekly Standard and serial liar Bill Kristol bloviating about character and courage.
The President’s commutation of Libby’s jail term is nothing more nor less than obstruction of justice. Had Bush issued a pardon, Libby would have been compelled to testify were he to be called before any of the multiple ongoing Congressional investigations of the administration. Since Bush only commuted the jail term, Libby conveniently retains his Fifth Amendment protection against self-incrimination.
As for the $250,000 fine and Libby’s “forever damaged” reputation, these parts of the sentence are supposed to constitute sufficient punishment and assure us that Libby is not getting off easy. That claim might be true for someone who wasn’t a powerful political operative. However, it’s pretty safe to assume that like so many disgraced and scandal-plagued Republican officials and pundits before him, Libby will find a highly-paid position with a well-connected conservative think-tank, thereby rendering his punishment rather toothless.